Whistles and clappers: A revolution this is not

Monday was the day of the Bangkok Shutdown. You may have read about it in the news. It's the latest in a series of sad events for Thailand led by a Suthep Thaugsuban, a former Democrat lawmaker who has himself previously been the subject of numerous corruption scandals. Oh and he was also indicted for ordering army crackdowns on Red Shirt protesters in 2010. Ninety-two people died then. Role model he ain't. What we have now in Thailand is a serious attempt to overthrow the government under the guise of "democratic reform". They want less democracy for Thailand.

The fact that the Democrat Party are involved is an immediate red flag. Thailand's Democrat Party are anything but democratic in their intentions. They can't win an election to save their lives so they're pulling out all the stops they can in order to kick out Yingluck Shinawatra, Thailand's now-caretaker prime minister whose party won the general election in 2011. She is, of course, the sister of Thaksin Shinawatra. We all know that. Thaksin, as his detractors love to point out, is the root of all that is wrong in Thailand. He also is certainly no angel, but this goes beyond one man. This is about the future of the country.

At the Bangkok Shutdown thousands of people have occupied various busy parts of Bangkok, complete with tents and sleeping mats. It's not really a shutdown, though. Bangkok more or less functioned as normal Monday with the exception of a number of mall closures. About 140 schools also had to close and many people worked from home. The streets in central Bangkok quiet and there were fewer cars on the road, which if anything was a good thing. How many people were out there is difficult to gauge. Reports put it at somewhere in the tens of thousands (up to 100,000 total?). That's near the truth, but it's nowhere near the kind of numbers you'd expect if this movement is something a large section of society support — and it's nowhere near the number Suthep et al have claimed.

This isn't a popular movement. In fact, I think it's incredibly disjointed. I wanted to see for myself just how much of a mess this has become, so I spent some time Monday around Ratchprasong and Asok, getting a mere snapshot, no doubt, but it was enough. It was pathetic. There were a lot of people there, certainly, but it was depressing on so many levels.

At Asok, I listened as a noisy cover band belted out The Final Countdown, We Are The Champions and What's Up by 4 Non Blondes. There were all kinds of people there from all kinds of places. Were they friendly? I guess. They weren't unfriendly. They actually looked bored for the most part. The ludicrous Michael Yon gushed that this this was "the friendliest massive protest ever". He actually wrote that. Taking everything at face value as he does, Yon has apparently made himself right at home acting as the unofficial English-language spokesperson for Suthep and co.

Late in the afternoon, a rabble of marching whistlers approached the protest area. As it drew nearer, this is what I saw.

Yes. A shiny new Merc. That was the vehicle leading Suthep's group as they strolled up the road. You could not have scripted a more ironic scene. A bunch of people claiming to speak for the entire country, rolling up in a vehicle that is the epitome of wealth, luxury and privilege. A few more people passed and there he was, the man the Asia Society proclaimed "person of the year" after an online poll that really served no purpose. Suthep beat Malala Yousafzai by more than 100,000 votes. Now that is ridiculous.

It would be all too easy to get caught up in the theatrics of what Suthep and those pulling his strings are doing. But then you'd find yourself sounding like Michael Yon. Yes, on the surface, democratic reform sounds like it makes sense, but that isn't what this movement represents. What it represents is, dare I say it, fascistic to the core. These people don't want the election on February 2. In fact, many of them don't want elections at all. They want an appointed council. They want to rob the people of Thailand the opportunity to chose who their government is. I'm not saying Thailand's general elections are perfect. The choices aren't great. But they are choices nonetheless.

Many of the people at these protests would rather these choices did not exist. I say "many" and not "all" because I don't believe everyone at these protests is firmly behind the overall goal. I have friends and colleagues and acquaintances who have been out there on the streets at one time or other these past few weeks and I wouldn't necessarily call them fascists. I'd call them confused. They want change, but they don't really know how to articulate this.

Put this in the context of the Bangkok Shutdown and you have a whole bunch of people out on the streets who have come together without really knowing why. At Ratchprasong, there were again a lot of people, but they were mostly asleep, and if they weren't asleep they looked sure looked it, clapping their clappers and whistling robotically after every sentence that came booming out of the sound system, taking selfies all the while

While rhetoric, hyperbole and outright lies rained down from the stages, nationalistic imagery was everywhere. T-shirts, face paint, hats, bandanas, placards, whistles, hand clappers: everything was emblazoned with the Thai flag. It was like being at an EDL rally in the UK without the beer and constant abuse. It was as if reaffirming their national identity was all they had in common, but more importantly, it was like they were thumbing their noses up at the rest of the country, suggesting everyone else is somehow less than Thai.

That's the problem. There is an enormous amount of condescension in this country. Look at the likes of Chitpas Kridakorn, the Singha heiress who said that "many Thais lack a true understanding of democracy… especially in the rural areas". This kind of point of view is common. It's just a shame that Chitpas is such a prominent figure. Some people listen to her. They can relate to her. They feel a connection. It's sad. This whole movement is sad. Just look at the T-shirts that were on sale right next to the main stage at Ratchprasong. Is this something you'd want to be a part of?

How about these placards, particularly the one on the left? Is that cool? Is that a serious political movement?

I don't blog much about Thai politics these days — I don't blog much at all really — but some things need to be said. What happens next for Thailand is out of these people's hands. They're being used. The reasons why they're being used go deep into a subject area that is above my pay grade and something I'm uncomfortable blogging about while I'm in Thailand, but the clues are there. There are those who would stop at nothing — civil war is a possibility — to get what they want here.

I will no doubt take some flak for writing a blog post like this, but I'm frustrated with what's been happening in Thailand and it's been going on for so long now that I don't know how I feel any more about this country. Call me what you will, but these are my personal thoughts. No stress. That's enough words for now.

Note: I took all the pics on this page.

Social media buttons:

16 thoughts on “Whistles and clappers: A revolution this is not

  1. Finally, someone with a clear understanding and rational head that is doing some objective reporting. Sometimes its difficult for us 'outsiders' to figure out what this country is all about, and this is one situation where one see the total insanity of how things work here.

    But as they say, TIT.

  2. Are all these pics yours or have you lifted them from others? If they are from others you should cite your sources.

    If others have stolen them from you they should be citing you as the source.

    A simple statement like "The photos on this page were taken by the author" would further legitamise your writing and remind people to cite their sources as I have seen these images in a few other blogs.

  3. Thanks for this. I completely agree with you. Have these people actually did their research on this Suthep Thaugsuban? Have they wondered the powers that be behind this man? I can see dictatorship unfolding in this country, and yes, fascists to the core indeed.

  4. good comments, but dont quite hit the mark
    underneath Thailand is feudal society, with one of the most poorly educated, uncritical, brainwashed populace – not an autocracy but an idiocracy
    both sides are used by demagogues and a real reform/rev is needed

  5. Very well written article, thanks Matt.

    To me Thai politics is a school example of how democracy is not a guarantee for the best decisions or leadership. That being said, there is no easy solution here, the majority has chosen a Thaksin puppet before and would do it again. As you wrote, the current alternative certainly is no better so it's a very difficult choice between the least bad.

    These latest developments reaffirm my fear for what is about the happen to this country once H.M. The King would decease …

  6. I do agree with you Matt. more than 80% of my colleges support every demonstration lately. I really don't understand how much they get brainwashed this much. many of them get PhD from western countries. The director of the school and administrators close the school for couple time already to support the protest, even now. It is really old for me, I came back from the state to work for my country, To see this kind of environment, it really discourage to me. They complain about their workload, but they have time to design shutdown t-shirts, prepare food for the protesters, join every protests even though they are workdays.

  7. I just walked from my place,near victory monuments to see what's going on outside after keeping myself in the room and work for couples days. I'm glad to see many people that did not have anything to show they are protesters at least.

  8. Bit one-sided. What is your take on 2010 compared to the current protests?
    I tend to agree somewhat with the current protests. Change is needed AND it can NOT be done with new elections. But total non-communication to discuss is wrong. Clearly there are many ppl who want something and clearl there's someone or something blocking what they want.

  9. Your pictures…very nice to support your story line and pull some old sure fire shots. The old swastika is beating on a dead horse. Selfies…yes we know by now…yingluck? There are thousands of those from any Red-shirt protest. The tent-camp…sure..where people inside or is it all empty?

  10. I tend to agree with everything written here. You've focused on the current protests without talking about the Red shirts much. But I think it's important to consider that even if Suthep was to succeed in getting his unelected "people's council" implemented, all that would do is encourage the Red shirts to take to the streets again to oppose it. And this time they'd be justified in doing so. His solution is about as undemocratic as it gets.

  11. A simplistic and shallow summary. You have taken your stance ( which is your right ), but you have failed to delve into any reasons why these people are protesting.

    One of your claims "They don't want elections" is plainly inaccurate. You lost any credibility or impartiality at that point.

  12. Well written and ignore the moronic statements from the moronic Thai Visa posters above. Some people (mainly old white dudes who can never leave) would prefer to keep the poor in their place, they liked it better that way. Everything was cheaper for them ;)
    The arrogance on Suthep and his clueless mob is incredible. They are collectively too clueless to win an election so they chose not to fight in one. Cowards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *